The Pot, the Preconditions, and the Problem with Atheism

Atheism borrows tools it can’t explain. In this debate, I challenged an agnostic atheist to account for logic, science, and morality without God—and when pressed, he had to invent universe-making aliens. This article unpacks why only the Christian worldview supplies the necessary preconditions of intelligibility—and why denying that ends in absurdity.

Apologetics, ArticlesJoel SettecaseMay 22, 2025presuppositional apologetics, Christian worldview, atheism vs Christianity, laws of logic, morality without God, uniformity of nature, transcendental argument, impossibility of the contrary, agnostic atheist debate, grounding for logic, biblical epistemology, Van Til apologetics, Joel Settecase debate, Christian apologetics blog, defending the faith, intelligibility and God, presuppositionalism explained, debate with atheist, Christian logic and reason, truth and the Bible, Presuppositional Apologetics books, Presuppositional apologetics vs classical apologetics, Presuppositional apologetics definition, Presuppositional apologetics PDF, Presuppositional apologetics reddit, Presuppositional definition, Presuppositional apologetics criticism, Presuppositional apologetics examplesComment